Writing guide
From ideato bill.
A step-by-step guide to writing a policy proposal lawmakers can actually act on.
- 01
Pick a specific problem
Name the problem, who can fix it, and exactly what you want them to do.
Before you write anything, answer three questions in one sentence each:
- What is the problem? Who is affected, and how?
- Who can fix it? The General Assembly, the Board of Education, your school board, or your city council.
- What exactly do you want them to do? Pass a law, change a regulation, adopt a policy, or fund a program.
Weak
“Mental health”
Strong
“Virginia high schools have one counselor per 350 students”
If you cannot answer all three yet, do more research first. A vague ask is the most common reason proposals get sent back.
- 02
Find the evidence
Back every claim with a source a lawyer can check.
Use at least three of these:
- Government data from the Virginia Department of Education, U.S. Department of Education, Census, or CDC.
- Research from peer-reviewed journals or established research groups.
- News coverage of specific incidents.
- Local data you collect yourself: a student survey, a public records (FOIA) request, or school board minutes.
Every number needs a source. Open and read every source yourself.
- 03
Look up the current law
Find what the law says today and the gap your proposal fills.
- law.lis.virginia.gov for the Code of Virginia. Search by keyword, then read the full section.
- lis.virginia.gov for past bills. Check whether someone already tried this, and what happened.
- Your school division's policy manual, usually on the division website under School Board, then Policies.
Then name the gap: in two to four sentences, say exactly what current law fails to cover. This is the hole your proposal fills, and it is the part lawyers care about most.
- 04
See what other states did
Show lawmakers the idea already works somewhere else.
Lawmakers are much more comfortable voting for something that has worked somewhere else. Find one to three examples.
- ncsl.org, the National Conference of State Legislatures.
- ecs.org, the Education Commission of the States.
No other state has done it? Say so. Being first is a selling point, as long as you show why it still works.
- 05
Write your recommendations
Three to five numbered actions, each tied to a specific body.
Write three to five numbered recommendations, most important first. For each one, state:
- What: the specific action.
- Who acts: the General Assembly, Board of Education, school board, or another body.
- Why it works: one or two sentences tied to your evidence.
- 06
Draft the bill
Turn your recommendations into real bill or policy language.
Seven rules for bill language
- 1“Shall” vs “may”. “Shall” means required. “May” means allowed.
- 2Define terms. Say exactly what counts and what does not.
- 3Say who acts. “Each school board shall” is enforceable. “Schools will” is not.
- 4Be specific. “Within 30 days,” not “promptly.”
- 5Add exceptions. Plan for emergencies, safety, and court orders.
- 6Enforce or report. Name who reports, to whom, and how often.
- 7Amend when possible. Adding to an existing Code section beats starting from scratch.
Bill skeleton
- Title
- A BILL to amend the Code of Virginia by adding a section numbered 22.1-[000], relating to [topic].
- Enacting clause
- Be it enacted by the General Assembly of Virginia:
- Definitions
- A. As used in this section, “[term]” means [definition].
- Requirements
- B. Each school board shall [required action] within [30] days of [event].
- Exceptions
- C. Subsection B shall not apply when [emergency, safety threat, court order].
- Reporting
- D. Each school board shall report annually to the Department of Education by [date] on [data].
- Effective date
- 2. That the provisions of this act shall become effective on July 1, [year].
You cannot introduce a bill yourself. A legislator has to sponsor it. Your draft makes their job easier and shows you are serious.
Going to a school board? School boards adopt policies, not bills. The template includes a policy version for that.
- 07
Answer the other side
Answer the three strongest objections before anyone raises them.
Lawmakers will hear the other side from lobbyists, administrators, and companies. Pick the three strongest objections, not the easiest ones.
- State each objection fairly, the way an opponent would.
- Answer it with evidence.
- If it is partly right, say so and show how your bill handles it, usually with an exception or a phase-in.
Common ones: it costs too much, it burdens schools, it should be a local decision, or it creates safety risks.
- 08
Check and submit
Run the checklist, save as PDF, and send it in.
- My ask is specific and aimed at a body that can actually do it
- The executive summary fits on one page and stands on its own
- Every number has a citation, and I opened every source myself
- My bill uses “shall” for requirements and defines every key term
- It includes exceptions, a reporting piece, and an effective date
- I deleted every gray note and [bracket] from the template
- Someone else read it and could explain it back to me
- It is saved as a PDF, and a parent or guardian approved it if I am under 18
Every submission gets a response within 3 weeks. No exceptions.
After it's done
Who tosend it to
A new state law
Send it to
Your own delegate and state senator, plus members of the House Education or Senate Education and Health committeeWhen
Fall, before session starts in JanuaryA statewide rule
Send it to
Virginia Board of EducationWhen
Any time. Check their calendar for public comment.A change in your district
Send it to
Your local school boardWhen
Before a board meeting with public commentA change in your city
Send it to
City council or board of supervisorsWhen
Before a council meeting
Find your legislators at whosmy.virginiageneralassembly.gov. Start with the people who represent you. They care most about their own constituents.
Policy Library
See realexamples
MANGO's own proposals follow the same structure. Read one before you start.
Questions
Quickanswers
8 to 15 pages, including the draft bill and sources. Longer is not better. A legislative aide reads the first page and skims the rest.
Yes. List every author on the title page and in the submission form.
For research only. Verify every fact against the original source. AI tools invent citations and misquote laws.
Feedback on your paper from our advisors at Gordon Dodson. Legal review covers your policy paper. It is not legal advice or legal representation.